Canche logo elcanche - words & images from Guatemala
Journal

December 11, 2005

Adiós Survivor: Guatemala

Survivor: GuatemalaIt appears that Guatemala's 15 minutes of fame have come to an end.

Tonight was the final episode of Survivor: Guatemala. As a service to my readers, I made the sacrifice of sitting though the final two-hour special. (What, you think I'm exaggerating? I actually had to pass up an episode of the West Wing for this drivel.)

If you notice a tone of resentment in this journal entry it's probably due to the fact that tonight a young woman, Danni Boatwright, received ONE MILLION DOLLARS for "surviving" 39 days in Guatemala. Meanwhile I've been "surviving" here for 16 years and can't get anyone to pick up my lunch tab.

Anyway, here is my final thought on this reality tv series: I guess it wasn't as harmful as I had feared, nor as helpful as I had hoped.

I haven't read any reports of ecological damage from the presence of the cast, crew, and staff who invaded the protected archeological site to film the series. (Although I am guessing that some clear-cutting had to take place to build the mega-maze used in tonight's show, for example.)

On the other hand, my hope that the show would somehow generate an interest in, and knowledge of, Guatemala seems to be overly optimistic.

It wasn't until tonight's program that some real, live Guatemalans make a guest appearance on the show. (That's right: at the end of 39 days surviving in Guatemala, the contestants actually get to meet a few of the people who actually live here!)

A group of five indigenous men and women arrive at the Survivor camp to perform a Mayan ceremony. Sadly, viewers aren't enlightened as to the significance of the ceremony (the colored candles, the honey, the spices, etc.) but instead have to depend on the half-cocked comments of the confused contestants.

During the brief ceremony a chicken is sacrificed (something I have never seen in any of the Mayan ceremonies I've attended) and thrown in the fire.

Sadly, the post-ceremony conversation of the "survivors" centers not on the social, cultural, or religious implications of the event that they were privileged to attend but rather... whether they should eat the chicken (after being told by one of the Mayan priests that this wasn't allowed.)

Once the Guatemalans depart from the scene, three of the four remaining contestants agree to devour the burnt chicken carcass left in the ashes. Shortly thereafter a wicked thunderstorm descends on the camp and the worried gringos wonder if they've angered the Mayan gods.

Pissed-off gods or no, it certainly was a pathetic conclusion to one of the few truly cultural moments on the show.

When the two-hour ordeal had finally ended I was amazed. Amazed, that is, that the show hadn't completely ruined my appetite. (My respect for American culture was crushed, but not my hunger.)

I decided to walk to a nearby Pollo Campero for a late night chicken dinner (fried, not sacrificed).

As I was eating my "pollo frito", a young Mayan girl, maybe five years old, accidentally backed into my chair. I looked at her, and she looked at me. Suddenly a huge smile lit across her beautiful face. "Buenas noches" I said, as she broke into a fit of giggles and ran off to join her sisters.

And then it hit me:

If it meant being allowed to stay here for only 39 days, I wouldn't want to be a contestant on... or even the winner of... Survivor Guatemala. You can keep the million dollars, because I have the true prize: when tomorrow comes, I'll still be here.

Tags: , , , ,

Posted by elcanche at December 11, 2005 11:03 PM
Comments

Great Commentary Rob. Thanks for sharing. Love, Marisa (p.s. see you in a few days!!)

Posted by: Marisa at December 12, 2005 10:35 AM

When anybody asks me why you have been there so long, I tell them, "Because he loves his job, the Guatemalan people, and the country."

Posted by: Mom at December 12, 2005 11:11 AM

I beg to differ, i know for a fact that other guatemalans appeared on the show, the waitressess sp? in one of the episodes where one contestant won a dinner for three i think, while the other ate very small almost burnt fish. it was an even shorter guest appearance i guess.

I highly doubt there was any impact, there are farms not far from the actual archaelogical site, or rather i hope there wasnt any, the actual site is quite a sight, i didnt watch the show much (thankfully?) so i dont know if the site per se was in it or just mentioned to be nearby. As stiff as the laws are in regards to archaelogical sites i'm affraid they are just as cheap to buy out the authorities.

Posted by: chema at December 13, 2005 07:26 PM

Estimado Chema,

I must have missed the episode with the Guatemalan waitresses (from your description, though, that was probably for the best, no?)

And you're absolutely right... it seems to me that the problem in Guatemala isn't the laws themselves (archeological, or otherwise) but rather the lack of enforcement of those laws. It would also seem that this weak enforcement is, in many cases, both the cause and the result of corruption.

Thanks for your input!

Rob

Posted by: Rob at December 13, 2005 07:42 PM

To know the people of Guatemala is to love them. Go there once and your heart will never be the same.

Posted by: Robert Cruickshank at December 14, 2005 03:36 PM
Global Voices Online - The world is talking. Are you listening?
Blogalaxia
Powered by
Movable Type 2.64
rob@elcanche.com ©2006 text & images